May 30, 2012 . . . around 1000 hrs. I’d forgotten taking this foto until a conversation with Harold Tartell this afternoon. RIP . . . Bounty in that foto was heading for Newburgh, NY. Note the USCG vessel lower right.
Here are more fotos from my harbor jaunt yesterday… Apollo Bulker now lies at the dock in Rensselaer.
John A. Noble passed the Statue on the Upper Bay at midday yesterday.
Lower Manhattan yesterday was a maze of pumps powered by portable generators of all sizes. I’m not sure where this water is being pumped from. But waters in other parts of that area smelled of fuel; people wearing masks–there’s a whole new meaning to Halloween mask now–ran pumps and threw out waterlogged debris from residences and businesses.
Google “John B. Caddell” now and you’ll see lots of stories describing this vessels as a “168′ water tanker” or a “700-ton water tanker.” It’s NOT a water tanker. It was built as hull # 137 for Chester A. Poling Inc. to transport petroleum. Soon after delivery, it was turned over to the Navy and redubbed YO-140. After the war, ownership was returned to the Poling company, and until its sale “foreign” about two years ago. It’s NOT a water tanker . . . it did not transport water as a paying cargo.
It’s remarkable to see the number of government helicopters in the skies over New York–and the military trucks and personnel. This afternoon I spoke with US Forest Service crew in my neighborhood–Queens–clearing roadways: the person I talked to, from Arkansas, had never been in NYC before. He said he was working with USFS crews from Texas, Wisconsin, and Ohio. Thanks, welcome to NYC, and come back sometime when we’re all feeling better.
And finally, attributed to the Daily News . . . LARCs come ashore on Belle Harbor, Queens to assist. Click on the foto to get the Daily News story.
All fotos by Will Van Dorp, except that story and fantastic foto by Vera Chinese the NY Daily News.
After coming home last night, I finally finished reading Rockwell Kent‘s 1929 memoir N by E. Rockwell Kent lived for a time on the curve at 1262 Richmond Terrace (Staten Island) just east of the Caddell Dry Dock. N by E tells the story of his shipwreck on the western shore of Greenland near Godthaab and subsequent struggle to survive. Here are some teaser excerpts.
“We lay, caught in the angle of a giant step of rock, keel on the tread and starboard side on the riser; held there by wind and sea; held there to lift and pound; to lift so buoyantly on every wave; to drop–crashing our 13 iron-shod tons on granite. There, the perfection of our ship revealed itself; only, that having struck just once, she ever lived, a ship, to lift and strike again. … wind, storm, snow, rain, hail, lightning and thunder, earthquake and flood.” (page 132) Some time later, the three crew save what supplies they can and scramble up the rocks to safety. Kent again: ”The three men stand there looking at it all [including the wreckage of their vessel Direction] … at last one of them speaks. ’It’s right,’ he says, ‘that we should pay for beautiful things. And being here in this spot, now, is worth traveling a thousand miles for, and all that it has cost us. Maybe we have lived only to be here now.’” (144) And later “It was clear to us that the boat would remain on the ledge and even be, at low tide, partly out of the water. She appeared to have been completely gutted … the forecastle hatch now stood uncovered and every sea came spouting through it like a geyser, bearing some quaint contribution to the picturesque assortment that littered the rocks and water. Books, paper, painting canvas, shoes, socks, eggs, potatoes: we fished up what we could.” (148)
Somehow Kent found himself ennobled in that personal disaster. There’s hope. It’s also a good read.
Last foto here passed along by Justin Zizes Jr . . partly submerged fishing boat in Sheepshead Bay.






















11 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 4, 2012 at 9:58 pm
JED
Beachmaster Unit 2 (BMU-2) is based out of Joint Expeitionary Base Little Creek / Fort Story (JEBLCFS). LARC-V : Lighter, Amphibious Replenishment, Cargo; 5-ton.
November 4, 2012 at 10:26 pm
tugster
jed– thanks.
November 4, 2012 at 11:11 pm
Harold E. Tartell
Nice photo of the BOUNTY Will with Miss Liberty. A few months ago she was in Newburgh, now she is no more. No one ever knows the fate of these vessels. Like people, we have to enjoy them to the fullest while they are still here with us.
November 5, 2012 at 7:33 am
Tony Acabono
Will, the John B. Caddell was being stored at the Sea Knights marina where it must have broken loose from it’s mooring. The sale of the vessel has a court injunction, there is a lien on the vessel relating to a lawsuit from when three crewmembers were killed aboard her. She was built as a petroleum product tanker but did in fact haul water as a paying cargo. During severe droughts in NYC she would travel up the Hudson to about Chelsea and fill her tanks with fresh water. She would then take this water to various NJ oil refineries. Fresh water is required as part of the refining process.
November 5, 2012 at 8:05 am
tugster
tony– thanks for the clarification, and i stand corrected.
November 5, 2012 at 1:06 pm
starbuck5250
My son-in-law’s NY National Guard unit just came back from Afghanistan. Now, they’ve re-activated and deployed to NYC. Good luck to all trying to stay warm and dry out.
November 5, 2012 at 2:53 pm
tugster
thank him for me. also, tell him welcome to nyc. cheers
November 5, 2012 at 8:46 pm
Harold E. Tartell
Getting back to the subject of JOHN B. CADDELL classified as a water tanker. I don’t want to keep this going on into an argumentative situation. The CADDELL was built to haul petroleum products, and is classified as a products tanker. All tankers carrying petroleum products for that matter could be classified as water tankers. After they complete discharging cargo they take on water ballast. The older tankers used the products tanks to hold ballast water. The newer tankers now have separate ballast water tanks which are segregated from the product tanks. If we want to get technical, I was dispatching for the Hudson River Pilots back in the 1980′s. Esso tankers (ESSO KURE http://www.aukevisser.nl/inter/id328.htm, ESSO SHIMIZU, http://www.aukevisser.nl/inter/id342.htm, ESSO SAINT JOHN, http://www.aukevisser.nl/inter/id367.htm to name a few that I remember, would discharge cargoes of jet fuel from Aruba at the Exxon Bayway Refinery, sail up the Hudson River to either Hyde Park or Port Ewen, & anchor. They would flush cargo tanks take on fresh water (because this area of the river is not brackish), and sail back to Aruba where the water was sold, and also used in the refinery.
The Hudson River Fishermen’s Association got wind of this, & there was HELL to pay. http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=861&dat=19831127&id=LzMcAAAAIBAJ&sjid=3VgEAAAAIBAJ&pg=3851,7883471, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riverkeeper (read this article), http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0,,20118115,00.html. Exxon ended up paying some hefty fines, because there was sufficient proof and evidence of what was taking place. The taking on of fresh water for Exxon came to a screeching halt.
To sum things up, these ships were carrying water for a paying cargo, but were not classified as water tankers. Like the CADDELL, they were built for the petroleum trade, and are classified as PETROLEUM PRODUCTS TANKERS.
November 6, 2012 at 5:10 am
Tony Acabono
Sir, as a mate on one of the last remaining US flag small product tankers in NY harbor, I would like to clarify a few things: I agree the news media bungled the John B. Caddell Story. What they failed to mention was that it was an obsolete ship, that was in storage and not an active unit.
There are or were some vessels that were specifically designed to carry water, usually barges. Their purpose was to provide ships with fresh potable water, this was before reverse osmosis and other technologies were invented..
There is a remaining example of a water barge at the pier at SUNY Maritime college. I believe that the US Navy still has a distillation ship whose sole purpose is to provide water to other ships and troops debarked ashore.
Our wonderful Riverkeeper put a stop to exchanging ballast water in the Hudson many years ago. It is suspected Zebra mussels and other invasive species were introduced in this manner.
November 6, 2012 at 8:06 am
tugster
tony and harold– thanks much for adding the details that i could not provide. good points.
November 6, 2012 at 4:04 pm
Harold E. Tartell
Tony, K-Sea Transportation Had A Potable Water Barge Named AQUA. Since The Buyout By Kirby, I Don’t Know The Present Status Of The Barge Or The Service That It Provided. The Navy Had Several Water Distilling Ships http://www.navsource.org/archives/09/45/45idx.htm, & Water Barges, Both Self-Propelled & Non Self Propelled http://www.navsource.org/archives/14/17idx.htm. Some Of These Water Barges Came To The Aid Of The Nuclear Power Plant Stricken By The Earthquake & Tsunami In Japan To Help In Cooling Of The Overheated Plant, & Prevent A Meltdown. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/26/us-assists-japan-nuclear-plant-fresh-water_n_840938.html, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpQdnyLxZ0I, http://ntdtv.org/en/news/world/asia/2011-03-28/u-s-barge-cools-nuclear-plant-in-japan.html